Film Review: Avedon
Who Needs a Plot When You Have Richard Avedon?
By Christine Merser | Screen Thoughts

Why is Ron Howard making a documentary about Richard Avedon when he could be making another rom-com? I would happily watch another Splash. But I’ve been thinking about what happens when filmmakers who know exactly how to make an invented story feel real get their hands on a real story better than anything they might have invented. And there’s something funny about asking Ron Howard why he’s doing this now. He’s already made documentaries about the Beatles, Pavarotti and Jim Henson. He says he’s curious about people who make extraordinary things over and over again, across an entire lifetime. I went into Avedon, which just dropped on Netflix, wondering why he chose a photographer. I came out thinking he’d found another director.
Does every documentary have a plot? I’m not sure. Avedon does. An odd boy, riddled with guilt because he can’t learn the way school wants him to and knows how much this disappoints his father, gets behind a camera and discovers everything genius about himself. In the Merchant Marine, he’s assigned to take identification pictures. Imagine being given the dullest job in photography and finding, somewhere in that long line of baffled faces, what you want to do for the rest of your life. Years later, he turns the camera on his dying father. The boy who couldn’t give his father what he wanted gets to decide how the rest of us will see him. I’d have bought a ticket for that movie.
What I never knew was how much story Avedon had in his head before he took a picture. Watching the footage Howard pulls out of the archive, I started to imagine a whole script for each ad or portrait. Something had just happened. Something was about to happen. And Avedon was an actor in the scene. He was just never in the picture. Well, that’s not true, actually. There he is in the home movies and behind-the-scenes photographs, right alongside the person he’s photographing. Howard lets you watch the man who ordinarily disappears when the picture goes to print. Then you see the picture again, and there he is.
And yes, I was so happy to go back to what came between Brooke Shields and her Calvins. If we only knew then what we know now. I remembered the line perfectly. I’d forgotten how young she looked saying it. That’s a strange little trick of nostalgia. You get to have the pleasure of remembering something and the discomfort of seeing it again, sometimes in the same five seconds.

I kept coming back to that blank white canvas Avedon liked to put behind people. He could have given you a whole landscape painting to tell you where you were and what sort of person you were looking at. He gave you a face and left you there with it. It made me wonder what would have happened if he’d worked with Edward Hopper. Put an Avedon face in a Hopper room and I’d spend the whole time trying to decide whether to look at the person or out the window. I’d also pay to hear the two of them discuss which one of them got to have the window.
It turns out Howard wanted something similar from his interviews. He brought in Robert Chappell, who shot The Fog of War, because he wanted that feeling you get when somebody looks straight into the lens and seems to be talking to you. I’d spent half the film wondering what Avedon said to make people look at him that way. Then I realized Howard was trying to get people to look at me that way, too.

These days it’s shoved down our throats that we can’t care what anybody thinks of anything w
e do. The only person whose opinion matters is our own. I don’t even know what that means. I’m glad Howard left room for what one review can do to a person who, by any reasonable measure, had earned the right to never give a damn again. Gene Thornton went to Minneapolis to review an exhibition that covered twenty-five years of Avedon’s work for The New York Times. The Chicago Seven were on the wall, fully clothed. The bodies Thornton got hung up on belonged to Allen Ginsberg and Peter Orlovsky. Avedon remembered reading what was supposed to be a review of his life’s work and feeling as though the rest of the pictures might as well have stayed home. The way Howard tells it, the review hurt him so badly he struggled to click the shutter for a year. I thought about that boy and his father again. And here I am, writing a review.
Which brings me, by a route I promise I did not plan, to Elizabeth Holmes’s partner and his penis. In Nathan Fielder and Lance Oppenheim’s You Can See Everything, Billy Evans takes a shower, the camera stays, and the title makes good on its promise. It was his idea, apparently. A24 is campaigning for Best Picture as well as Best Documentary, so the shower may yet have an awards season. I thought of Thornton, who had an entire Avedon exhibition in front of him and couldn’t get past two naked men. Then I thought about Evans, who invited the camera in. He could decide what to show the filmmakers. They got to decide what the rest of us would see.
Meanwhile, Aaron Sorkin took the actual Chicago Seven and gave them dialogue so good I’d like to believe people talk that way when the stakes are high. In my experience, the line you needed comes to you in the cab home. In a Sorkin movie, it comes to you right there in the courtroom, and thank God for that. Sorkin gets a real trial and writes the lines. Howard gets a stack of photographs and home movies and finds a plot. Fielder and Oppenheim show up to film the last month before Holmes goes to prison, and Billy Evans offers them a scene. There are mergers and acquisitions everywhere these days. Apparently documentary and narrative film have been in talks, too.
Maybe this is what I mean when I say there’s no truth anymore. There’s the truth of what happened, and then there’s the version somebody wants me to see. Avedon could take everything out of the frame except a person and still leave me with his version of that person. Howard puts him back in the frame, and now I want to go back through every damn picture and see what I missed the first time. Oh my God, there are a lot of them. Talk about a prolific life. Don’t miss this film. Thanks, Ron.



Comments